'Not every story is told in that way': Phil Spencer says that live service games aren't the answer to every problem, and that smaller games play an important role

Phil Spencer giving a talk on stage, wearing a t-shirt with an 'X' on it.
(Image credit: Microsoft)

Live service games are treated like some great and powerful cheat code for generating awesome amounts of shareholder value. It's so great that a third of "triple-A developers" are working on live service games as we speak. But despite what it may seem, not everyone is interested in seeing these kinds of games dominate the big budget side of the industry.

"I didn’t want to see every game turn into some big service based game because they felt like that’s where the business model was," Xbox boss Phil Spencer says in an interview with Xbox Era. "It’s not easy to do that. Not every story is told in that way. Not every game kind of s that or creative idea s that business model."

Easy for Spencer to say, of course. When Xbox currently has some of the biggest live service games under its umbrella: Especially after the South of Midnight are on track to be released in a couple of months.

"I think it’s an important part of our industry because not every story is going to be 100 hours long, and not every medium is going to have some kind of mechanic that has a currency and everything else," Spencer says. "They just want to tell their story and move. Some of my favourite games going back to like Limbo and stuff, these are fantastic games that I want to see continue in our industry."

Despite what can at times seem like a strong push for more live service games, there are a ton of developers who, like Spencer, want to keep on giving players complete stories. A few former he'll never make a live service game no matter what EA thinks: "It will not happen with a Hazelight game, ever."

Naturally, Xbox isn’t swearing off live service games for good. It's big enough that it can invest in various kinds of games, "part of our reason for trying to get a subscription going was to allow us to also games that have a beginning, middle, and end," Spencer says. But knowing that there's a legitimate attempt to not just rely on live service is still quite reassuring, especially for those of us who are pretty sick of them right now.

2025 gamesBest PC gamesFree PC gamesBest FPS gamesBest RPGsBest co-op games

Best co-op games: Better together

TOPICS
Elie Gould
News Writer

Elie is a news writer with an unhealthy love of horror games—even though their greatest fear is being chased. When they're not screaming or hiding, there's a good chance you'll find them testing their metal in metroidvanias or just iring their Pokemon TCG collection. Elie has previously worked at TechRadar Gaming as a staff writer and studied at JOMEC in International Journalism and Documentaries – spending their free time filming short docs about Smash Bros. or any indie game that crossed their path.